A method for making an expanded shoe sole includes the steps of (a) molding a first foamable material to form an unexpanded sole blank, and cooling the unexpanded sole blank to harden the unexpanded sole blank, (b) positioning the hardened unexpanded sole blank on a first mold, (c) heating a second mold to a molding temperature, (d) positioning assembly of the hardened unexpanded sole blank and the first mold in the second mold, (d) filling a second foamable material in the second mold prior to expansion and cross-linking of the hardened unexpanded sole blank, and (e) thermally molding the second foamable material and the hardened unexpanded sole blank in the second mold.